The Hat: Arendt Meets Heidegger

The Hat: Arendt Meets Heidegger is an opera that imagines the meeting of Hannah Arendt and Martin Heidegger, two greatly influential thinkers of the 20th century, who sustained a relationship despite their disparate perspectives and background. Arendt, a Jew, was known for her Origins of Totalitarianismamong other works of political theory; Heidegger, whose Being and Time is a classic philosophy text, was an active member of the Nazi party.  Arendt and Heidegger’s story is a love story; but it is also a story of philosophy and epistemology, student/teacher and hierarchical relationships, and political and social relevance.  With a touch of humor, it is an opera with much to appeal to people who may or may not be familiar with the Arendt’s and Heidegger’s writings.
This new opera is a collaborative creative project by myself and the writer and artist Zsuzsanna Ardó, who wrote the libretto.  The libretto is based on Zsuzsanna’s play of the same title, published on both sides of the Atlantic.  The play’s rave reviews include praise from Dr. Martine van Ittersum of the University of Dundee—“Philosophy and sex make for a surprisingly potent combination. Utterly compelling and thought-provoking”—and Rick Lewis, editor of Philosophy Now—“She has clearly done some remarkably detailed reading to make sure her account of their first meeting is consistent with all the known facts – but her real achievement is to make their meeting and their subsequent affair/seducti­on/meeting of minds believable in human terms. The script crackles with intellectual and sexual tension.”  (Here are some more reviews.)
My music draws on the soundscapes of Arendt and Heidegger’s worlds, with hints of Jewish and German folk music as well as the European Classical music that they would have listened to together.  The musical language, though, my own, with my characteristic polyrhythmic intricacy and melodic lyricism.  My concept for the opera involves all singers and instrumentalists being present on-stage at all times.  When a singer’s character is not in a given scene, that singer will join the instrumentalists at the perimeter of the stage as part of the ensemble.  Projections will replace scenery, and the ensemble will literally blend into the background.
The fully staged and orchestrated version of The Hat was premiered by Thompson Street Opera Company in Chicago, on April 4th, 5th, and 6th 2019 at 8:00pm and April 7th 2019 at 3:00pm at the Broadway Theatre at the Pride Arts Center.  The production featured singers Emelia Clark, William Roberts, Liana Gineitis and Matthew Peckham, with Executive and Artistic Director Claire DiVizio and Music Director Alexandra Enyart.  Oxford Opera Company had to cancel the UK premiere in 2020 due to COVID and plans to reschedule have not yet been made.
The first complete scene was previewed by Opera On Tap in Brooklyn in 2014, to critical acclaim.  The critic Trav S.D. wrote, “I found the scene endlessly clever and funny… Siegel’s music seemed on the same page, both intellectually and emotionally.”  Opera On Tap presented this scene on their New Brew series at Barbès on Friday, April 4, 2014, featuring the singers Alison CheesemanSeth GilmanAlex Guerrero, and Anne Hiatt; pianist Amir Khosrowpour; and myself as guest conductor. A reading of the full opera as part of the Composers Now Festival was presented at the Lounge at Dixon Place on February 4, 2017, featuring baritone Christopher Dylan Herbert and myself in the title roles, with mezzo-soprano Alison Cheeseman, tenor Alex Guerrero, conductor Colin Britt, and pianist Trudy Chan (above photos from this 2017 performance). Please contact me to request video footage from the reading and premiere.
Shopping Cart